Meet the cookie that turns every bite into pure joy. Our Milky Mingle Cookie is a bakery-thick masterpiece where creamy milk chocolate chips melt into ribbons of sweetness alongside colorful, candy-coated mini M&M’s that bring a playful pop in every bite.
With its buttery, golden edge giving way to a soft, chewy center, this cookie delivers the perfect contrast of textures — rich chocolate creaminess, delicate vanilla warmth, and a satisfying candy crunch.
Hand-scooped and crafted in small batches, each cookie is generously topped with extra mix-ins for that irresistible, bakery-window look.
Whether you’re savoring one with an ice-cold glass of milk, sharing a box with friends, or gifting a pack to brighten someone’s day, the Milky Mingle Cookie is comfort, color, and chocolatey bliss in one bite.
Milky Mingle Cookie
🛍️ Pre-Order Required for Pickup
This item is available by pre-order only and will be ready for pickup starting at 8:00 AM on the next market day. Orders are packed in labeled bags and placed inside The Bread Barn™ (6920 Combs Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46237)for self-serve pickup.⏰ Please note: The Bread Barn™ may close early once sold out to the public, but pre-orders will remain available through at least 12:00 PM (noon).
📦 Items are freshly prepared, cooled, and packaged for your convenience. Your bag will be clearly labeled and ready for easy pickup inside The Bread Barn™.